The European Mortgage Federation (EMF) acknowledges last week’s agreement by the European Parliament (EP) Plenary on the draft Mortgage Credit Directive (MCD) and looks forward to final adoption by the EP and Council. On the whole, the EMF welcomes the future Directive as clarification of practices which have been in existence in Member States for decades.
However, the EMF would like to set the record straight with respect to the misleading reporting that has since emerged, both in Member States and in Brussels, in relation to the provision stating that “Member States shall not prevent the parties to a credit agreement from expressly agreeing that return or transfer to the creditor of the security or proceeds from the sale of the security is sufficient to repay the credit”. Contrary to what is being implied in some reports, this provision does not, in any way, introduce a new regime that would allow borrowers to terminate their contract by “handing back the keys”. What this provision does do is confirm the existing principle of contractual freedom that allows parties to a contract - i.e. lenders and borrowers, to bilaterally agree specific contractual terms, where not otherwise stipulated by law.
It is worth recalling that borrowers’ ability to “hand back the keys” (non-recourse loans) was at the core of the US subprime crisis, and there is no place for such a regime in an EU system where creditworthiness assessment has always been the basis for loan-granting procedures. The introduction of such a regime in the EU would negate the fundamental role of long-established legal principles regarding the role of the collateral, which underpins the mortgage lending business, and could therefore endanger its future.
“The European mortgage industry would like to reiterate that mortgage lenders in the EU are committed to not only helping people own their homes but to remain in them, and that foreclosure is, and will remain, a last resort in the event of financial difficulty, after all other solutions have been exhausted”.
Annik Lambert, EMF Secretary General
The EMF firmly believes that it is in the interest of all stakeholders - borrowers, lenders and governments alike, that the provisions of the future MCD are accurately presented and reported to the public at large.
Contacts:
Annik Lambert
Secretary General
Tel: : +32 2 285 40 44
alambert@hypo.org [1]
Jennifer Johnson
Head of Legal Affairs
Tel: : +32 2 285 40 45
jjohnson@hypo.org [2]
Notes to the Editor:
Links:
[1] mailto:alambert@hypo.org
[2] mailto:jjohnson@hypo.org
[3] http://pr.euractiv.com/sites/default/files/pr/EMF%20Press%20Release%20-%20EMF%20Clarifies%20Reports%20on%20MCD%2018.09.13.pdf