ANEC Statement on accessibility of voting

Date

29 May 2009

Sections

Health & Consumers
InfoSociety

For many European voters, the question is which party to vote for. But for others, it is how to vote.

From 4 to 7 June 2009, millions of citizens will have the chance to vote in the elections to the European Parliament. Most will be able to cast their votes without problem. But others will find themselves disenfranchised through reasons of older age or disability. And they constitute more then 10% of voters.
ANEC believes all those entitled to vote should be able to do so. And in secret. Modern solutions and standards should be used to help everyone exercise democratic choice.

Access to on-line information material and eVoting systems

There is no unified European electoral law as many details are decided at the national level. The use of electronic voting is one aspect that depends on the national, or even regional, rules[1].

Today’s technology allows votes to be cast through the internet, portable devices, even interactive television and mobile phones. For example, Estonia was the first European country to permit internet voting in October 2005 for local elections[2]. This was possible through most of the population having an electronic identity card so facilitating voter identification and security of the vote. However, the use of electronic voting systems, based on internet or on touch screens, can be particularly challenging for people with visual impairments. If the colour contrast of the screen is not good, or the web page cannot be read by the special software used by blind people (known as the screen reader), a person with visual impairment cannot vote independently.

In ANEC’s opinion, the usual problems of access to mainstream electronic products and services can be found in the systems used for electronic voting. But the chance to vote is a democratic right. And it should be exercised independently.

Moreover, much electoral material is not accessible to disabled people. According to a survey carried on by the Belgian association of disabled people in 2006, most visually impaired voters had problems to familiarise themselves with campaign material due to websites not allowing access or documents being printed in too small a font[3].

Of seven European political parties, none declared their website to be compliant with the web accessibility standards (WCAG 0.1-0.2)[4].

The recent US Presidential Election demonstrated that citizens are increasingly turning to websites as a source of information or political networking. The use of Web 2.0 and new social networking technologies by the Obama campaign has transformed political dynamics. Obama's Facebook page had 2.6 million fans. YouTube users spent 14.5 million hours watching official Obama campaign videos. ANEC believes it essential to ensure such technologies are accessible to all citizens, whatever their age and abilities.

What can be done?

eVoting systems are bought by authorities through public procurement procedures. According to the European Public Procurement Directives, it is possible to integrate social considerations - and specifically Design for All and Accessibility requirements - in the contracts for public bids[5]. ANEC urges the development of accessibility standards which can be cited in the tenders for eVoting systems.[6].

The advent of Web 2.0, which brings new opportunities of user interaction, reaffirms the need for more web accessibility. ANEC calls for electoral material on-line to be made accessible. This is part of our long-standing request for a horizontal legislative framework able to address the accessibility of ICT products and services, including web accessibility[7].

Access to voting premises

It should not be forgotten that, in order to exercise their right to vote, citizens need to be able to access the premises where elections take place, generally public buildings such as schools and town halls.

Accessibility to the built environment is one of ANEC’s main priorities. We are currently contributing to a draft international standard on access to the built environment, which should be adopted soon[8]. Regarding the applicability of the future standard to existing buildings - such as town halls - we believe care must be taken to ensure that ‘buildings listed as having significant heritage value’ are still made as accessible as possible.

What can be done?

ANEC calls for work on access to the built environment to start as soon as possible at the European level[9]. Standards are needed in the framework of public procurement procedures in order to help public authorities define accessibility criteria in their public tenders. How to assess if a ramp is not too steep? And at which height should the handle be placed on a door for a wheelchair user to be able to use it?

Jobs

The Council of the Notariats of the European Union (CNUE)
Project Manager
EASO - European Asylum Support Office
ICT Assistant – Business Analyst (EASO/2019/TA/018)
EASO - European Asylum Support Office
Certification Officer/Didactic Officer (EASO/2019/TA/017)
EASO - European Asylum Support Office
Research Officer (EASO/2019/TA/014)
EASO - European Asylum Support Office
Information and Analysis Officer (EASO/2019/TA/012)
EASO - European Asylum Support Office
Head of ICT Sector (EASO/2019/TA/011)
European Cyber Security Organisation (ECSO)
Policy Manager
EASO - European Asylum Support Office
COI Portal Officer (EASO/2019/CA/004)
FiscalNote Europe
Intern
AND Consulting Group
Research Officer